Deciding on the brand of tyres was considerably more difficult than the wheels, because there are quite a few good quality, aggressive all-terrain tyres available currently. After initial research, I narrowed my choices down to (Click to see manufacturer's website):
The last tyres I ran on my 200-series were the Nitto Ridge Grapplers, and I was extremely happy with them. They offered excellent on and off-road performance, were extremely durable (with no punctures) and lasted well. Prior to the Nittos, I ran a set of Mickey Thompson Baja ATZP3s. They also offered excellent performance and durability, but they were somewhat noisier to begin with, and became very noisy by the end of their life. I discovered that the tread blocks on the ATZP3 wore unevenly, in a 'sawtooth' pattern, which is common with 4-block tread designs such as most Mud-Terrain tyres. Because I didn't want a noisy tyre, I didn't consider them this time around.
The second tyre that interested me was the Maxxis Razr AT811. The tread pattern of the Razr is almost identical to the Ridge Grappler, and they have received excellent reviews since their release.
I discounted the Toyo and Duratrac reasonably early in the process. The Toyo had poor availability in the sizing I wanted, as did the Duratrac. There was also an absence of quality reviews on the Duratrac, so I decided to leave it off the list this time around, but with new tyres and reviews appearing all the time, it's worth re-examining options each time you're up for a set of new rubber.
So this time, I was left with the RAZR vs the Ridge Grappler. These are very closely matched in specification. Their tread patterns are very similar (see photo above). Both offer 3-ply sidewalls with aggressive shoulder tread. They generally share the same load and speed ratings for a given size. The Nittos come from the USA, and the RAZRs come from Taiwan. Independent reviews for each were excellent. I had previous experience with the Nittos, but not the RAZRs. The RAZRs did have a price advantage, being about $50 per tyre cheaper than the Nittos.
Given previous experience, I was leaning towards the Nitto Ridge Grapplers, but when I checked availability in my preferred size of 33x12.5R18, the Nittos were at low stock levels. This shortage helped me choose the Maxxis RAZR, which were readily available.
At the time of writing, I've now had the wheels and tyres fitted for several months, and have done about 5,000km of mostly on-road driving on them.
The RAZRs have met or exceeded my expectations so far, with excellent on-road performance in both wet and dry conditions, matching the Ridge Grapplers I ran previously. In addition to the good performance, I have been amazed by how quiet they are. I had considered the Ridge Grappler to be a quiet tyre, but the RAZRs set a new bar for an all-terrain. They are barely -if at all- noisier than the factory tyres. Even when driving beside a concrete barrier with the windows down, there is no obtrusive noise from the tyres. Time will tell if this noise level continues as the tyres wear.
The only downside I can identify so far is they seem more prone to picking up stones than the Ridge Grapplers. This can be a little frustrating, listening to the ticking of stones on the tar after driving on a gravel road.
They seem to be wearing well so far, but I'll really need to run them for some time before I get a good indication of their expected life.